A customer clicks a link on Google, lands on “Page not found” and leaves. You never see it happen. Here is what 404 errors and redirects really do to a small-business website, and how to fix them without breaking anything.
Short version
A 404 means the page does not exist. A few are normal. Google does not say 404s lower your whole site’s rankings, but a page that returns 404 drops out of search, and every visitor who lands on it leaves. Fix important ones with a 301 redirect to the closest live page, and update your own links.
404, 410 and soft 404: what each one means
- 404 (not found): the page is not there. Google treats it like other 4xx errors: the URL is dropped from the index if it was listed, and newly found 404 pages are not processed.
- 410 (gone): the page is gone on purpose. Google handles it much like a 404.
- Soft 404: a page that returns a normal 200 status but looks like an error, such as an empty page or a “nothing here” message. Search Console reports these because the server is saying one thing and the page another.
- 5xx (server errors): these are worse. Google slows its crawling in proportion to the errors and removes URLs that keep returning them.
What broken pages actually cost you
Not rankings across the whole site, according to Google’s documentation. The real costs are simpler. People who follow an old link, a printed card or another site’s link to a dead page leave. The page you removed stops showing in search. And if you redesigned the site and changed addresses without redirects, you may have thrown away pages that used to bring visitors. That is the most common way a redesign loses traffic. See our website redesign SEO checklist.
301 or 302: which redirect to use
Use a 301 (permanent) when a page has moved for good. Google treats the target as the main address and shows it in results. Use a 302 (temporary) for short-term changes; the old address can stay in results. Prefer server-side redirects, and point old addresses to the closest matching page, not to the home page for everything. Sending every old URL to the home page looks lazy to people and is often treated as a soft 404.
Keep redirects to one step. A chain such as http to https to www to the final page makes visitors wait, and Lighthouse flags multiple redirects as a speed problem.
How to find broken links and 404 errors
- Search Console: the Pages report lists URLs Google tried and could not find, and shows soft 404s.
- A link checker: free browser and desktop tools crawl your own site and list links that fail.
- Your own site: click the main menu, footer and top service pages on a phone. It takes five minutes.
- Your analytics: pages that get visits but show a “not found” title.
How to fix them in WordPress
- Fix the link if it is your own: edit the page and point it to the right address.
- If the old page should lead somewhere, add a 301 redirect. SEO plugins such as Rank Math include a free redirects module, or you can add rules on the server.
- If a page is gone and has no replacement, a 404 or 410 is correct. Make the 404 page helpful with a search box and links to your main pages.
- Re-test after the change and request a re-crawl in Search Console for important pages.
Frequently asked questions
Do 404 errors hurt SEO?
Google’s documentation does not say they hurt a site overall. The affected pages drop from the index, and visitors who land there leave.
Should I redirect every 404 to the home page?
No. Redirect to the closest relevant page. If there is none, leave the 404.
How do I check my whole website for errors?
Start with the free Website Health Check for speed and basics. It does not crawl every link, so send us your address if you want a full review.
Next step
Want us to check links, redirects and the rest? Request the full report from the Website Health Check page. Not showing in Google at all? Read why your website may not show up on Google.
Sources: Google: HTTP status codes and network errors, Google: Redirects and Google Search.
Related service
Want help with this? See our Web Design page for plans and pricing, or get a free quote.









